The annual competition signals the end of the competitive calendar for the Isle of Man Photographic Society, and it is a highly-anticipated event, always involving a well-qualified judge imported from one of our neighbouring islands especially for the occasion.
This year our judge was Robert Millin DPAGB BPE5* LRPS EFIAP/b AFIAP EPSA UPI Hermes – clearly garlanded with awards, and astonishingly, all accumulated in the past five years, since taking up photography as a hobby (though described by himself more realistically as an obsession)!
In addition he is a member of Wigan 10, a very select group of just 11 photographers who do not compete among themselves but mentor each other for the purpose of external competitions both personal and as a club – and who are now four-times FIAP (International Federation of Photographic Art) club world champions. So, a formidable judge, used to working at the very highest levels of quality.
The format of our two-day event is that prints are judged on the first day, digitally projected images on the second.
The judge reviews all the entries during a morning session, and – given the sheer number of entries – is then expected to comment only upon the winning selection in the evening. This is then followed by a showing of personal work – which is always stimulating and inspirational for the members.
The process of judging a photograph is admittedly subjective, though there are obvious requirements for technical quality, artistic input and impact – and Robert proved an excellent judge, sharing his thought process as to why some images succeeded and others did not.
It was clear that technical quality was essential – images lacking sharpness and clarity in key areas or distracting highlights, for example, were marked down.
However, he was also generous in his comments and awards, commending those who were willing to ‘stretch boundaries’ and try new techniques or a different viewpoint to get the effect they wanted.
While the general standard of work was excellent, Robert felt that ‘creative’ was the one area where more work was required.
‘Creative’ in the photographic world is now defined more as ‘altered reality’, and usually requires a high level of artistic imagination as well as computer skills to merge a number of different images to create a seamless finished work. The effect is often that the final image stretches credibility, but is realistic enough to require a second or third look.
The awards are too numerous to go through in detail, but the best mono print in the competition and winning the Mackie Cup was ‘Hunt the Wren’, a superb portrait by Sue Jones, while the best colour print was a lovely Italian landscape ‘Heaven and Earth’ by Ruth Nicholls, which won the Redwood Trophy.
To finish our evening, Robert’s presentation – with lots of helpful advice - confirmed a primary interest in sports and travel photography, but his ‘addiction’ to competitions requires him to provide images on a wide range of subjects, so his work covers many topics and genres.
However, success comes at a cost – both financial and in terms of time and effort.
Robert is now retired so time is available, and lives near Chester, which means many world class sporting events held in the Manchester/Liverpool/North Wales area are accessible – identifying and attending as many of these as possible maximises the opportunity to build and develop a portfolio of work.
Obtaining a press pass to ensure the best vantage points, offering non-distracting backgrounds for example, is helpful in achieving success. As regards his travel portfolio, Robert pointed out that, living as we do on the Isle of Man, travel photography doesn’t have to mean long distance – one’s own locality provides many opportunities for successful images which demonstrate culture, landscape and way of life.
Brenda Shimmin gave the vote of thanks for a very good evening.
Annual Print Competition Results:
Standard Section – Mono (Tranter Cup) : Mike Trout (1), Beryl Quayle (2), Joy Brodie (3, VHC & C), Richard Shafto (HC). Colour (Woodbourne Cup): Beryl Quayle (1 & C), Thomas Carr (2), Richard Shafto (3 & VHC), Mike Trout (HC). Natural History (Baldwin Shield) : Beryl Quayle (1, 2xC), Richard Shafto (2), Michael Howland (3 & C), Mike Trout (VHC, HC & C). Creative(Greeba Cup) : Joy Brodie (1). Record (Dreemfroy Trophy) : Beryl Quayle (1), Richard Shafto (2), Joy Brodie (3 & VHC). Intermediate Section – Mono (Ballure Cup) : Chris Nicholls (1,2,3,VHC & HC). Colour (Coombe Cup): Chris Nicholls (1, 2, 3 & VHC), Ian Lumsden (VHC, 2xC), Shirley Lotfy (2xC). Natural History (Ballaragh Cup) : Shirley Lotfy (1, 3 & VHC),Chris Nicholls (2). Creative (Carnane Cup) : Nessie Gillen (1). Record (Lezayre Trophy) : Nessie Gillen (1 & C), Shirley Lotfy (2 & VHC).
Advanced Section – Mono (Bridge Cup) : Sue Jones (1, VHC & C), Ruth Nicholls (2, VHC, 2xC), Nigel Owen (3, VHC & C), Ron Shimmin (3xC).
Colour (Sanderson Cup) : Ruth Nicholls (1,3, VHC & C), Ron Shimmin (2, 2xC), Nigel Owen (VHC & C), Mark Stringer (VHC & C), Chris Blyth (C), Sue Jones (C). Natural History (Caraghan Cup): Chris Blyth (1,2 & C). Creative (Snaefell Cup) : Ruth Nicholls (1 & 2), Sue Jones (C), Mark Stringer (C). Record (Glenrigh Cup): Ron Shimmin (1 & 2).
Chris Blyth