Treasury have told Douglas North MHK John Houghton there is no record of him ever submitting his form to start paying voluntary pension contributions.
And the chief financial officer Malcolm Couch says it would be inappropriate to send any member a reminder that they are not making voluntary contributions.
We revealed yesterday that Mr Houghton was the only MHK not paying towards his pension.
He insists that he thought he was paying as he had apparently submitted a form to Treasury payroll back in April 2012.
But in an email exchange, Mr Couch told him: ‘There is no record of you submitting the appropriate form to Treasury Payroll.
‘Had we received and acted upon the form authorising voluntary contributions to be deducted, you would have seen an appreciable reduction in your monthly salary, and under DEDUCTIONS your payslip would have shown the line “Tynwald Members Pension Scheme”.
‘Similarly, there is no record of any correspondence or contact from you regarding the Members Pension Scheme since the new arrangements began.
‘This is, as approved by Tynwald, a voluntary scheme. Members needed to return the form in order for their voluntary contributions to the scheme to be set up. It would have been inappropriate for Treasury Payroll to send you, or any Member, reminders that you were not making voluntary contributions to the pension scheme.’
In a statement sent to Tynwald members, Mr Houghton claimed events had shown Treasury in a ‘poor light’ and if reminders had been sent out ‘none of those witch hunts on members would have happened’.
Mr Houghton says he did not check, and does not keep, his payslips. He has shown iomtoday his bank statements which show his take home pay fell by more than £1,000 between April and May 2012 and rose again by nearly £270 in June of that year.