More than 150 people crammed into Patrick Community Centre to voice their concerns over the potential sale of Knockaloe by the government.
The meeting was attended by Minister for Environment, Food and Agriculture Richard Ronan MHK, Glenfaba MHK David Anderson and Patrick commissioners.
Last month iomtoday revealed that the government was considering selling the former experimental farm, which was also home to thousands of internees during the First World War.
Captain of the Parish Pat Costain opened the meeting, which was standing room only as passionate locals filled the hall.
Mr Ronan told the gathered crowd that Knockaloe would not be sold to property developers such as Dandara or used to build a sewage facility.
‘Certainly I have made no decision, and this is absolute honesty from me, I have made no decision on Knockaloe,’ said Mr Ronan.
‘Are we going to fill Knockaloe full of Dandara houses? No we’re not.
‘That’s not going to happen. Do I need to put that to bed?
‘I can assure everyone in this room there’s been no offers from property developers.
‘I would be set against that anyway. If that is a rumour, let’s just put that to bed.
‘I want to assess all the options. What I want to hear is ideas, what do we want to happen?
‘Leaving it alone, is that feasible? The old farmhouse is derelict.
‘Any decision has to be the right one for the community and the farming industry.
‘There’s nothing to stop the likes of Sir Alfred McAlpine making an offer, I can’t predict the future, but I doubt that will happen and I would be set against that.
‘I’m determined to see food production and agriculture grow in the Isle of Man.’
There were also questions about a sewage treatment area being built at Knockaloe, another rumour that was strenuously dismissed.
Mr Ronan said: ‘Let me just read out what Manx Utilities have said on this “We have not received the final feasibility study from our consultants, however the siting of a sewage treatment works at Knockaloe is not the preferred option.”. So I can publicly say tonight, that a sewage treatment plant will not be in Knockaloe.’
Earlier Patrick commissioner David Talbot had told the audience that they had been looking into the legal position regarding selling the land.
He said: ‘The land was initially donated by the Henry Bloom Noble Trust and we have been looking at whether there is any covenant. Our research wasn’t conclusive. Further investigation is needed into the Henry Bloom Noble Trust papers, legal advice would be needed and we have hesitated at that point, as obviously that costs money.’
MHK David Anderson said: ‘The rumour mill has been been rife over the last few months. Knockaloe is an asset, it was left for the nation to use and I believe the government shouldn’t offload it.’
Other ideas that were mentioned included making Knockaloe a historical attraction with a visitors’ centre.
Peel commissioner Ian Davison said that he had spoken to DEFA about moving his ice cream factory to Knockaloe and also building a visitors’ centre with a small replica of the internment camp but said he had been told he needed £4m to buy the whole site.
Mr Talbot said that there were currently tenancy agreements in place with 15 years to run and these would have to be honoured so that would restrict what could be done with the site.
One member of the public, Brian Partington, asked: ‘Why the need to sell? People want this retained for the farming industry, this should have been used for young farmers to give them a start.’
Mr Ronan replied: ‘I hope it is retained for agricultural use, however that may be, that’s what I want to see, absolutely. We’ve got options, do we leave it as it is, do we rent it out as separate lots, do we sell it lock, stock and barrel, does it stay in government to protect the land, do we split the sale between properties and land, please understand I’ve taken a step back from this, I want to listen, it’s about making the right decision.’
Afterwards Mr Ronan issued the following statement: ‘I’d like to thank Mrs Costain, Captain of the Parish, and Patrick Commissioners for organising the meeting and so many local people for attending to let us know their views and to listen to some of our considerations.
‘As promised, my department will now discuss the matter further with Mr Anderson MHK and the commissioners in the coming weeks and months.
‘There were some exciting and innovative ideas and suggestions and what is important now is that we gather information, sit down and talk and follow these up in the right way in order to allow balanced decisions to be taken.’
Following a proposal from Mr Anderson MHK, the meeting resolved: ‘This meeting wishes the department to take note that we believe Knockaloe should remain in government ownership and be retained for agricultural, educational and community use.’
Mrs Costain also proposed that the meeting should be reconvened in six months to review progress.