Douglas North MHK Ralph Peake last week made a suggestion to the House of Keys that work permit restrictions should be dropped for a year to tackle the island’s skills shortage.
Mr Peake believes that it would allow businesses to offer attractive job opportunities for people looking to move to the island.
Minister for Economic Development Laurence Skelly urged caution, insisting the system was working well.
However, he said that a recent consultation found a lot of support for bringing in further work exemptions for roles in the financial and professional services industry, and further liberalisation of the work permit system as a whole.
The Examiner visited Douglas town centre to find out people’s views on whether it should be suspended for a year.
----------------------------
STEVE WOODWARD, 52, ANDREAS:
‘No, I don’t think it should be dropped. I just think it’s a fairer system to give local people better job prospects, especially the younger generation. If they’re bringing older people with more experience how are the younger ones going to get experience to fill the jobs? I just think it shouldn’t be dropped.
‘I don’t think dropping it would benefit the Manx economy, I think it’s better to keep it local and keep local jobs for local people. I think there could probably be better further education on the island, for example utilising the University College a bit more.
‘I think that would be a better option to boost the Manx economy, from my point of view anyway.’
----------------------------
DAVID WINNELL, 35, DOUGLAS:
‘I think if it’s temporarily suspended I don’t see that being a problem if it’s due to a skills shortage. The main benefit would be covering jobs that we can’t cover with the current workforce.
‘Obviously you don’t want to extend that out too widely to just anyone, it’s got to be for the jobs we can’t cover because obviously we want people living here to have a fair chance to get suitable work.
‘I suppose one of the first things that comes to mind, if they were to suspend it for a year, would be that people wouldn’t necessarily be able to get here easily.’
----------------------------
RACHEL RANSON, 36, ANDREAS:
‘I do personally think it should be scrapped for a year because I think we need to attract people to work over here in order to create an environment that has a bit of competition.
‘If you’re the best person for the job you should get the job, so if the local people are the best people for the job then they should get them.
‘I think over here we have a shortage of people that are good enough for the jobs at times so I think we’re hindering ourselves by not letting people come over and take those positions.
‘The work permits scheme limits the speed you can get people over here for employment, however there’s obviously ways round it that people have discovered over the years.
‘I don’t think it really serves what it’s supposed to do. I think it puts people off.
‘I have friends in all kinds of industries and they struggle sometimes to get the work permits correct when they are the best people to do that kind of work.’
----------------------------
LILLIAN COOPER, 68, WILLASTON:
‘Certainly it should be dropped. If we’ve got a skills shortage then we need more skilled people.
‘The situation is, to be quite honest, a lot of Manx people won’t do these things. If you’re going to make it awkward for people then they won’t come here, will they?’
----------------------------
SEAN DOYLE, 22, DOUGLAS:
‘I don’t really know if it should be dropped, obviously there are jobs that need to be taken.
‘I don’t know whether there’s a massive restriction on people coming over and whether they work.
‘I don’t think it would have a major effect and I don’t see why it would have a huge effect in a negative or positive way.
‘I think jobs should be open to everyone, nowadays everyone is everywhere, there’s different cultures and nationalities everywhere.’
----------------------------
REBECCA CHEETHAM, 32, DOUGLAS:
‘I got a work permit when I moved over in 2006 and it helped me get residency on the island.
‘My employer did it and sorted it all out for me.
‘I think the work permit brings people with new skill sets and there is a shortage of people with certain skills, so I think they should keep it but I do think you should recruit island-wide first.’